Mary Caye Smith
Why I'm Firefly

I was born and raised in Wauwatosa, met my husband Matt and raised our four kids there, so I know first hand what a special city it is! When we started our business, SalesSmith, in the basement of our Tosa home, our first and absolutely most valued employee was none other than Firefly’s Katie Wakefield…who also happens to be my niece!

When we sold our company, I started looking for a new chapter, and I couldn’t have found a better fit.  All of the virtues Firefly espouses resonate so much with me – honesty, dedication, integrity and hard work. I am so thrilled to be a part of this client-first company and to be able to work with this fantastic group of people.

We’ve owned two homes in Wauwatosa, one in Brookfield, and now reside on the east side in Whitefish Bay, which has so many great features similar to that Tosa charm we love so much. I know the metro market well and would love to be able to help you with any of your buying or selling needs!


  • Proud Homeowner in Whitefish Bay's Cumberland Forest Neighborhood
  • Licensed Realtor
  • Former President of SalesSmith, Inc.
  • BBA  in Marketing, University of Wisconsin-Madison

Contact Mary Caye